So I'm ending 2009 with a couple of my writing biases ... as I have quite a few. (Most of us writers do!) But this post is a bit of a lag reaction to an interview I did with a poet several months ago. We were both given a few classic questions:
1. Are writers born or made?
Friendly-neighborhood-poet-lady (no, I'm not anti-poet. In fact some of my favorite writers are poets, but you'll see where I'm going with this): She flipped her graying, unkempt hair and silky scarf and began to muse about how the mountains, the air she breathes, the scent of some unknown tropical flowers, and the untimely death of her poetry teachers in college (yeah, a bit, um, dark there) were just a few things that made her the writer she is today. (Shit, give me some of that air); that she breathed poetry, and the words on the page were her very existence. She was born to write and the lot of non-writers out there don't have a chance to achieve such sublime existence.
Ummm ... CRAP. (Okay, I didn't SAY that. Out loud. And I tried to keep the eye rolling to a minimum. It was a radio show, though, so the audience wouldn't have actually seen the eye rolling. Either way, it's not polite.)
Me: I'm homemade! I work my ass off. Yep. I have a vocation for it. Just as a surgeon has a vocation for what she does, a contract plumber, public accountant, farmer etc. all have "vocations". But everything I've achieved has been through hard work and great teachers (the novels I read for 25 years before beginning writing and my editors!). And It really pisses me off when somebody who writes says to people it's talent -- it's innate. Because unless you're one of those Picasso-types (which, from what I understand most of us aren't), talent has little to do with the success of a writer. It's discipline, desire, hard work. And when you throw the "talent card", you're especially telling a lot of young writers-to-be that they don't have a shot. That's. Not. Fair.
2. How important is publishing?
Poetry lady who's now grating on my nerves because she's so mannered and sighs too much: Oh! Publishing doesn't matter. In fact, I hate publishing because it's base. My words are for you, my listeners, for those sitting in a bar. The publishing houses just taint what's good and true about writing.
(My interpretation: CRAP.)
Me: VERY important. It's my job. It's what I want to do. Tell a teacher he can't teach anymore. Or tell a bus driver she can't drive a bus anymore. And no matter how many years I'm in this business, I'll always be wanting to get my words published because I feel like I have something to say and want to be heard. Publishing is a strange addiction. It's a rush. It's not ultimately why I write, but you can bet it's a big part of it. And as for publishing houses? They take huge risks on writers, novels, ideas etc. They put their necks on the line to bring books that might not necessarily sell loads to the market. Publishing houses are amazing entities that have given us novels like: The Road, Cannery Row, The Confederacy of Dunces, Octavian Nothing, Freeze Frame (yep, I'm grateful) and more.
Finally, our interview ended with
3. Any advice?
Poetry lady who clicks her nails on the table and breathes heavily (thinking she might have emphysema or maybe has spent too much time breathing more than mountain air): Find your muse and let the words come to you and flow onto the page. They'll be naked, bare, true. And that's your art.
(My interpretation: CRAP CRAP CRAP. Has she ever heard of revisions?? My bare, naked words are pretty much garbage ... ahem. But then again, I wasn't born to write.)
Me: Read. Read, read, read, read, read, read. Then work hard. Write. Join a writer's group. LISTEN. (Big one there: LISTEN) Listen to critiques. Listen to other writers. And inevitably your first novel will be a flaming pile of cow dung. But you'll finish it. And you'll write another one. And get better. And read, read, read, read, read. Get a thesaurus but DON'T SOUND LIKE A THESAURUS. And read, read, read. Oh yeah. And LISTEN.
Okay. Sure. It sounds like I'm being hard on the grate-on-my-nerves poetry lady. I get it. I get that she's created this personae and wants to be poetry. Fine. But don't go talking to kids, teens, or young writers about it so they feel like writing is this impossible obstacle because they weren't given a "gift." That's what bugs me. None of us are "given" anything in this world -- or very few are. And as soon as we throw those words around -- muses, talent and all that crap -- lots of kids will turn off and take a different road.
So that's my end-of-the-year rant!! Life is passion -- poetry. This is a hard job, just like any other. But if you're in, you're in, and it's worth the crazy ride.
Happy writing!









